May 29, 2026 bachelor insider
Joe Amabile Reveals How Much He’d ‘Sell His Soul For' to Become a Reality TV Villain: 'That’s It?'
Naming a price.
Fans first got to know couples Ashley Iaconetti and Jared Haibon, as well as Joe Amabile and Serena Pitt, on “Bachelor in Paradise” and other Bachelor Nation shows over the years.
Since their time on-screen, all four have continued updating followers on their lives online and frequently spend time together.
Recently, Ashley and Jared joined Joe and Serena on the “Not Married to This” podcast, where they asked the couple some very interesting questions.
Jared kicked things off by asking Joe how much he would “sell [his] soul for,” and without hesitation, Joe replied, “500 grand.”
In shock, Serena responded, “That’s it?” The Bachelor Nation star then reframed the question, asking Joe, “Let’s switch it up! How much would you sell your soul for, for us to be Bravo villains? For five years, on television, people hate us. We come across [as] disgustingly horrible people.”
As Joe thought it over, Jared chimed in, warning that he would be “taking a chance” because he “might not ever be able to redeem” himself.
Joe clarified, “So selling my soul is the internet not liking me?” Before quickly answering, “2 million.”
Ashley pointed out that Joe doesn’t seem to care as much, while Serena argued that the amount would need to be enough for them to live off forever.
Jared also noted that brand deals could disappear, prompting Joe to laugh and say, “Brand deals are gone anyways!”
Joe later shared the podcast clip on Instagram and captioned it with the quote, “What am I gonna do with a soul anyways?? -cousin greg”
Followers filled the comments with mixed reactions, with some finding the conversation hilarious and others feeling less amused.
We love catching up with our Bachelor Nation stars — and what an interesting question. We’re curious: what would your answer be?
